What traditional RPGs work for an Annihilation-style campaign?

November 19, 2026 4 answers
Asked by backdashByBriefcase

I'm looking for a game that can handle eerie exploration and encounters with the unknown. I prefer dice and a GM, rather than diceless, GM-less, or card-based systems. What would you recommend besides The Zone?

Answers

kartLineByColander

Call of Cthulhu is a good fit if you want the expedition to feel investigative and dangerous. The dice-based skill system supports scientists and other specialists, while combat is risky enough that studying a strange environment can feel more sensible than fighting it.

You would still need to create the altered landscape and its mysteries, but the system gives you a solid framework for discovery and psychological strain.

Reply to this answer
deckmulligan.net

I'd look at Mothership for a harsher science fiction take. It has a GM and dice, and its rules support fragile characters, stress, and dangerous exploration. Change the setting from space horror to an expedition into a transformed wilderness and you have a useful starting point.

Reply to this answer
DpadTangle

Delta Green could work if the part you want is a secretive organization sending a team into something it barely understands. It leans toward modern investigations and the toll they take on the characters. You would need to put more work into the ecology and extended wilderness travel yourself.

Reply to this answer
pixelCommuter

For a more action-oriented version, try Savage Worlds. It uses dice and a GM, and its flexible rules can handle a team with different specialties and encounters ranging from hazards to strange creatures.

One caveat for your preferences: it does use cards for initiative by default. You would need to replace that part with a dice-based method.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions