What tabletop RPG designers have talked about mistakes in their own systems?

November 22, 2026 1 answer
Asked by GBAcartPaperclip

I like hearing designers explain why they made a rule, how it affected play, and what they might change later. Are there good examples of that kind of reflection?

Answers

shmupLaneRookie

One example to look into is the discussion around Dungeons & Dragons 3.0 and system mastery. The concern is that a game can reward players for knowing which options are stronger while leaving newer players with choices that work less well in practice.

The source discussion points to Monte Cook having reflected on that emphasis as a mistake and having tried to address it in later work. It does not include the original interview or enough detail to pin down exactly which changes he credited as fixes, though. I would look for his own comments before treating a particular later rule as the intended correction.

kartSlipAngleMinder:

That distinction helps. A rule rewarding familiarity is not necessarily the same thing as a designer saying every complicated choice was a mistake.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions