What system would you use for a Planescape campaign?

November 20, 2026 5 answers
Asked by shmupBombFuse+Apron

I like Planescape, but the second edition rules don't do much to support the idea of beliefs shaping reality. What would you use instead?

I'm looking for something reasonably simple, with an old-school feel and manageable conversion from older material. Some mechanical encouragement for the setting's themes would be great, too.

Answers

P9throwOption~Late

I'd look at Whitehack. Its freeform character abilities and flexible magic seem like a good fit for a setting where identity and belief matter, while its old-school roots should make older adventures less of a leap than a completely different kind of game.

That said, flexible abilities are not the same thing as a built-in rule for belief reshaping the planes. You'd still need to agree with the group on when a conviction can affect the world.

shmupBombFuse+Apron:

That distinction helps. I'd be happy to add a small rule if the rest of the system gets close.

Reply to this answer
P5antiAir~Sleepy

Old-School Essentials is the straightforward pick if using older D&D material with minimal fuss is the priority. It won't solve the belief issue on its own, though. I'd add a simple reward for acting on a stated conviction when doing so causes trouble, then decide together what that reward can influence.

For larger changes to the planes, I'd keep those tied to campaign events rather than making every conviction an automatic reality-editing power. That preserves some mystery and gives factions room to matter.

Reply to this answer
DpadHeelFlick

Cypher System is worth a look if you want the themes to show up more directly in play, even though it moves away from the old-school feel. Character descriptors and GM intrusions give you places to bring beliefs and planar weirdness into the rules.

The tradeoff is conversion. Expect to translate creatures and challenges into Cypher terms rather than just dropping in old stats. If low-prep compatibility is the main goal, another old-school system is probably a better fit.

staminaMorsel_4K:

Intrusions can bring beliefs into play, but they don't automatically make belief reshape reality. That part would still need some campaign-specific work.

Reply to this answer
scrimRoster_3F

Worlds Without Number might suit a group that wants old-school adventure with more character options. It gives players room to make distinct characters, though that also means more choices to learn than a very stripped-down game.

I'd check the character creation rules before committing. Switching systems may make optimization feel fresh for a while, but a new system won't necessarily stop players from finding strong builds.

Reply to this answer
stealthBuild!NoFootsteps

Shadowdark is another option if you want a newer, fairly lean dungeon-oriented game. It could handle the adventuring side without asking everyone to learn a big rules set.

For Planescape's philosophical side, though, you'd be supplying much of the structure yourself. I'd choose it for the style of play first, not because it has a ready-made belief mechanic.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions