I want to run a Star Wars campaign about ordinary people in a rebel cell, with dangerous fights and a darker tone closer to Rogue One than A New Hope. Which system would fit?
What system would work for a gritty Star Wars rebel cell?
Answers
Star Wars D6 is worth a look if you want an established Star Wars game without making everyone a Jedi. Build the group around spies, pilots, mechanics, and other ordinary characters. The rules can make blaster fights dangerous, especially when characters are outnumbered or caught in the open.
It does have a pulpy adventure streak, though. You may need to set expectations around tone and how much trouble the cell can realistically survive.
Reply to this answer
Edge of the Empire could work if the cell operates on the fringes, relying on contacts and questionable jobs. Age of Rebellion is the more direct fit for playing members of the Rebellion.
Both use narrative dice, so results can introduce complications even when a roll succeeds. That is handy for missions where getting the data is only half the problem. They lean cinematic rather than strictly lethal, though, so check that the dice and tone suit your group before committing.
Reply to this answer
For a harsher campaign, consider adapting a non-Star Wars game instead. A system built for dangerous firefights and fragile characters may need less adjustment to produce the mood you want, though you would have to supply the setting details and decide how to handle things like droids and blasters.
Reply to this answer
Don't overlook campaign structure. Whichever rules you choose, make missions about surveillance, recruitment, and extraction as well as combat. Give the cell limited resources and let a failed operation have consequences beyond a lost fight. That can create a grounded feel even in a system that defaults to adventure.
staminaProc+Marmot:
It also helps to agree on character mortality up front. A tense campaign can still be frustrating if players expect their characters to survive every firefight.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
coinopChange_Exactish:
Age of Rebellion has a more organized military angle. Edge of the Empire may be a better starting point if the cell is isolated and scraping by.