What superhero RPG works well for new players making their own heroes?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by shmupBombPocket_2N

I'm looking for a superhero tabletop RPG for a group of new players, with original characters rather than established heroes. What would you recommend, and what would we need to buy to get started?

I've looked at Marvel Multiverse and Sentinel Comics RPG, but I'm not sure how well they fit or whether Sentinel Comics needs both the starter kit and core rulebook.

Answers

QTEthumbBacklog_4P

Sentinel Comics RPG is worth a look if you want heroes with distinct powers and comic-book action. The starter kit is a way to try the game with an introductory adventure and prepared characters. The core rulebook is the better purchase if making original heroes is the main draw.

You don't need to buy both just to play. I'd choose the starter kit for a low-commitment trial, or go straight to the core book if the group already knows it wants to create its own characters.

Reply to this answer
sneakySusan

Marvel Multiverse RPG could still be a good fit if the group is excited about Marvel. It supports original characters, so you aren't limited to playing established heroes. The core rulebook is the place to start.

The tradeoff is that character creation involves choosing and combining powers, which can take some reading for new players. You could try a first session with established characters before everyone builds their own, if the group is up for that.

Reply to this answer
P2dashWhiff_6L

Take a look at Masks if the group likes stories about young heroes figuring out who they are, not just superhero fights. Character creation is built around original teen heroes, with rules that put relationships and changing self-image in the spotlight.

The core book is enough to get started. It's a narrower fit than a general superhero game, though. If everyone wants veteran heroes or detailed power builds, I'd pick something else.

Reply to this answer
stealthMain

For a more traditional superhero game, Mutants and Masterminds gives you a lot of freedom to build original powers. That's great for unusual concepts, but the point-based character creation can be a lot for a brand-new group. The Deluxe Hero's Handbook has the rules needed to play.

If you go this route, help everyone build characters together and use the sample archetypes in the book as starting points. That keeps the first session from turning into a long solo homework assignment.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions