What strategy games make big empires hard to hold together?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by _respawnReceipt

I'm looking for a 4X or grand strategy game where expansion brings internal pressure and an empire can decline or collapse. I like the rise and fall feel of Ryse and Fall of Civilizations and Field of Glory: Empires. Mods are welcome too.

Answers

buttonBindBramble

Crusader Kings III is worth a look if you like internal politics as much as conquest. A large realm can become difficult to manage because vassals have their own interests, succession can divide territory, and factions can challenge the ruler.

It isn't a guaranteed cycle of rise and collapse, though. A stable dynasty can hold a large realm together, so the pressure depends a lot on how the campaign develops.

Reply to this answer
speedrunMiscalc

Try Stellaris if you want a space 4X. A growing empire faces increasing empire size penalties to things like research and traditions, so expansion has a cost even when your borders are secure.

That's more of a brake on growth than a detailed historical decline system. Unhappy planets and rebellious subjects can still create internal trouble, but don't expect every sprawling empire to fall apart.

Reply to this answer
arcadeMarqueeMarmot

Imperator: Rome has a lot of the pressures you're describing. Aggressive expansion can cause unrest, newly conquered populations may be unhappy, and disloyal governors or generals can contribute to civil wars.

There's a learning curve, but managing a mixed empire is a substantial part of the game rather than just a pause between wars.

Reply to this answer
arcadeCoinReturnee

For another Civilization IV option, look at the Dawn of Civilization mod. It builds on the historical rise and fall idea, with stability playing a role in whether civilizations hold together. That sounds closer to what you're after than a general penalty for owning too many cities.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions