What should I try if I like the ideas in Blades in the Dark but not the rules?

November 21, 2026 3 answers
Asked by coinopPayoutMeter

I love the setting, factions, playbooks, stress, and partial successes in Blades in the Dark, but its narrative mechanics feel dense and get between me and the roleplay. What could scratch a similar itch outside the Forged in the Dark family?

I'm also curious about Spire or Heart, though my group would rather avoid a campaign centered on playing an oppressed minority. Could either work with a very different premise?

Answers

lootQuickslotTrombone

I'd look at Spire if the setting and resistance premise appeal, but I wouldn't assume you can remove that premise without changing much else. Its character options and advancement are tied to the game's themes, so a different campaign would need some careful checking and probably some rewriting.

Heart is worth a look as a separate option rather than just a reskinned Spire. Compare what the characters are expected to pursue and how they advance with the campaign your group actually wants to play.

Reply to this answer
shmupFocusJitter_3V

Have you considered keeping Doskvol and running it with a system your group already enjoys? The haunted city, criminal crews, and rival factions don't have to go away just because the action rolls and position discussions aren't clicking.

You could start with your familiar rules and add only the bits you miss. A simple faction tracker can give rival groups plans and consequences without bringing over the whole Blades procedure. Stress and bargains would need more thought, especially if the original game's resource economy is part of what you liked.

buttonChordCache_3W:

That also lets the group try the setting before committing to a new ruleset. I'd leave partial successes out at first if adding them means renegotiating every roll.

Reply to this answer
mechHardpointPorridge

For a different direction, take a look at Into the Odd. It's a much lighter ruleset, so there is less machinery around each risky moment. You'd need to supply your own crew and faction setup, though, and it won't reproduce the stress and bargain mechanics you're asking for.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions