I'd like to use a short questionnaire to check whether a new player and the game are a good fit for each other. I would still meet them in person afterward. What questions would be useful?
What should I ask new players before inviting them to a game?
Answers
Start with the practical stuff: when are they available, how often do they want to play, and can they make the expected session length? A great match on everything else won't help much if the schedules don't line up.
Then ask what kind of game they enjoy. Do they prefer character interaction, combat, exploration, or a mix? What sort of tone are they hoping for? Give a brief description of your game too, so they can decide whether it appeals to them.
Reply to this answer
I'd include a question about content boundaries, but don't ask people to explain why they have them. Let them name subjects they don't want in the game or would prefer to handle offscreen, and give them a private way to raise concerns later.
Also ask how they prefer to handle a disagreement at the table. That can open a conversation about expectations without turning the form into a test with a secret correct answer.
Reply to this answer
Keep it short and leave room for actual conversation. A form can flag a mismatch, but a polished answer doesn't tell you everything about how someone will behave with the group.
After meeting, you could arrange a trial session with clear expectations on both sides. Make it clear that either the player or the group can decide afterward that it isn't the right fit.
ROMbankSwap_3L:
A trial session sounds like a good way to make the decision less dependent on the questionnaire alone.
Reply to this answer
Ask about experience, but don't treat it as a qualification unless your game genuinely requires it. A useful version might be: what games have you played, and is there anything you'd like help learning? That tells you more than just asking whether someone is a beginner.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
SpawnCamping:
Asking what they don't enjoy can be useful too. Someone may have trouble describing an ideal game but know which elements they want to avoid.