What should be on a session zero checklist, and what do people usually forget?

November 5, 2026 5 answers
Asked by lagline

I’m putting together my first short D&D 5e campaign for a group of friends and want session zero to actually set us up well.

What are the must-have items on your checklist, and what’s something people often forget to talk about until it causes trouble later?

Answers

m1dnight_roll

The big stuff is pretty standard: tone, table expectations, scheduling, character creation rules, and what kind of campaign everyone is signing up for. I’d also make sure you cover how you handle absences, level progression, house rules, and whether the game is more serious, goofy, tactical, or story-first. A lot of group friction starts when people assume the same vibe but mean totally different things.

What people forget most often is the boring logistics. Things like start time, how long a session actually runs, what happens if someone is late, whether phones are fine at the table, and how much between-session chat is okay. Those details sound minor, but they save a lot of annoyance later.

I’d also talk about safety and boundaries early, even if the group is all friends. Just a simple line on what subjects are off-limits, how to pause the game if something feels weird, and whether PvP or party conflict is allowed. That conversation tends to be way easier before the campaign starts than after somebody feels blindsided.

lagline:

The logistics part is a good point. I was mostly thinking about plot and characters, but I can already see how the scheduling stuff could get messy.

Reply to this answer
cratevibe

I’d keep session zero pretty practical. First, pitch the campaign in plain language so everyone knows what they’re buying into. Then settle character creation rules, party connections, and any limits on classes, species, books, or homebrew. After that, ask each player what kind of spotlight they want and what they absolutely do not want.

One thing that gets skipped a lot is group cohesion. If the characters are all independently built with no reason to care about each other, the first few sessions can feel awkward. I like having each player answer one simple question about why their character is with the party and one thing they already know about another character.

Another easy-to-miss topic is how you’ll handle rules disputes. Not every table needs the same level of rules lawyering, but it helps to say whether the DM makes a quick call in the moment and looks it up later, or whether you stop and check everything right away. That choice changes the whole flow of play.

soloRaven:

Party cohesion is huge. Half the time the campaign struggles because the characters can technically work together, but nobody made them feel like an actual group yet.

Reply to this answer
pocketmash

My checklist usually starts with three questions. What kind of story are we telling, how lethal is this game, and what does success look like for the group. If those are fuzzy, you get weird mismatches, like one player making a deep political build while another expects dungeon crawling and easy laughs.

After that, I get into consent and comfort lines. Not just the heavy-topic stuff, but also things like romance, body horror, torture, betrayal, gore, and player-versus-player conflict. People often think that means the game has to be sterile, but really it just means everyone knows what kind of content is on the table before it shows up in play.

Something I see forgotten a lot is treasure and advancement expectations. If players think they’ll level fast or get lots of magic items and the DM is planning a slower, grittier crawl, resentment builds fast. It helps to say upfront how rewards will work and how much you want character optimization to matter.

Reply to this answer
CTRLMICA

Honestly, I’d treat session zero as a contract for the table, not a pre-game chat. Get everyone to agree on attendance expectations, how long the campaign is supposed to run, whether side conversations are okay, and how you’ll handle missed sessions. Those unglamorous details matter more than people think.

The stuff people usually forget is social tone. Are jokes fine during serious scenes. Is rules debate okay in the moment. Can players split the party. Can someone try to steer the story in a totally different direction and expect the DM to roll with it. All of that affects the game way more than one extra house rule.

If I had to give one practical tip, I’d say leave time for each player to say what kind of moments they enjoy most. Some want combat, some want character drama, some want investigation, some just want to hang out and explore. A short round of that can tell you more than a long speech from the DM.

ember.thread:

Yeah, setting expectations for jokes and serious scenes is underrated. Some tables are fine with constant banter, others really need the emotional beats to land.

Reply to this answer
tactic~pup

I’d add one more thing that often gets missed, which is player agency around character secrets. If somebody wants a hidden backstory twist or private goal, make sure the rest of the group is okay with that style of play. Some tables love it, some tables get annoyed if they feel out of the loop.

Also, talk about what happens when someone wants to try a weird idea. Does the table reward creativity, or do you want to keep things tighter and more rules-bound. New groups often forget that and then one player is improvising wild solutions while another expects a much straighter game.

If this is your first campaign, keep the checklist short enough that people actually remember it. You can always revisit details later, but you want the first conversation to cover the basics clearly without turning into a lecture.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions