Until Dawn 2 is being developed with AdHoc Studio involved in the story. What would make its choices and characters work well in another horror game?
What should an Until Dawn sequel do with its choices and story?
Answers
Make the small choices matter as much as the obvious life-or-death ones. A conversation could change who trusts whom later, which might affect whether someone shares information or comes back to help.
That doesn't mean every line needs a whole separate ending. Different relationships can change the meaning of a scene even when the plot arrives at the same place.
Reply to this answer
Give players enough information to make a decision without making the outcome obvious. Horror needs surprises, but a character dying because of a completely arbitrary choice feels less tense and more like a guessing game.
Reply to this answer
I hope it doesn't treat keeping everyone alive as the only satisfying result. Let a death change the group and the rest of the story, rather than just removing that character from scenes. A messy ending can be memorable too.
Reply to this answer
The characters need to be fun to spend time with before things get gruesome. Sharp dialogue helps, but give them conflicting priorities and reasons to make bad calls under pressure. Otherwise the big decisions are just buttons attached to faces.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBAcartLatch_5P:
Consequences can still be unexpected. They just ought to make sense when you look back at what led to them.