My group enjoys building armies, conquering territory, and making tactical decisions, but handling large battles in D&D gets cumbersome. They prefer character options and strategic play over acting in character. What systems handle this better?
What RPGs work well when the players command whole armies?
Answers
Take a look at Birthright, a D&D setting built around characters who rule domains. It has rules for managing holdings and resolving wars with armies, so there is more support for conquest than in a typical D&D campaign.
It is an older edition of D&D, though, and its battles may not give your group the level of tactical detail they want. Check how the war rules play before committing to a campaign.
Reply to this answer
Reign is worth a look if the main attraction is building up an organization and using it to gain power. Its Company rules give groups a way to handle conflicts between larger forces without rolling for every soldier.
The tradeoff is that those rules are fairly abstract. If choosing formations and maneuvering individual units is the fun part, you might want a separate tabletop wargame for the battles instead.
Reply to this answer
For a more tactical route, try pairing an RPG with a miniature wargame rather than expecting one ruleset to do everything. Keep the RPG for characters, bargains, and gathering resources, then use something like Kings of War for army battles.
You'll need to agree on how campaign resources translate into units and how battle results affect the RPG. That takes some setup, but it also lets you pick the level of battlefield detail your group actually enjoys.
Reply to this answer
Check out An Echo, Resounding if you want an old-school fantasy campaign centered on domains and warfare. It covers managing territories and resolving battles, and it is designed to work alongside old-school fantasy RPGs.
That could fit the player-skill side of your request, though you should check whether its character options and battle detail are enough for your group.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions