Some players at our table enjoy character optimization, while others struggle with modifiers and tracking abilities in D&D. Are there games that give both kinds of player something to enjoy? Fantasy would be nice, but other settings are fine too.
What RPGs work for a group with mixed rules skills?
Answers
You might not need a whole new game yet. Try making the complicated bits visible at the table: put the final attack and skill bonuses next to the rolls, and use tokens or boxes on a card for spell slots and limited abilities.
For character choices, a player who likes building can help set up a straightforward character, then hand over a short menu of useful actions. Check that the player actually wants that help, though. Having someone else run your character's decisions can get old fast.
Reply to this answer
Take a look at Shadow of the Demon Lord if dark fantasy is on the table. Its core rolls are fairly direct, while its path combinations give character builders plenty to consider. The tone is grim, though, so check whether everyone wants that before choosing it.
Reply to this answer
Pathfinder Second Edition offers a lot of character-building choices, but I wouldn't pick it expecting less rules work than D&D. It may suit the optimizers while leaving the same tracking and learning problem for everyone else.
If you try it, start at a low level and use pregenerated characters or build together. That lets the group test the actual play experience before anyone spends hours making a character.
Reply to this answer
Consider Dungeon World if the group is willing to trade some detailed character optimization for a more fiction-focused fantasy game. The basic moves give players a smaller set of rules to learn, though the style of play is different from tactical D&D. It might be a good fit for the players who want less bookkeeping, but ask the builders whether that trade sounds fun to them too.
Reply to this answer
I'd run a short trial rather than commit to a campaign based on a rules description. Give everyone a ready-to-play character and see what happens when choices come up. Can the newer players tell what they can do? Do the optimizers still find interesting decisions during play?
Also ask whether the difficulty is remembering rules, keeping track of resources, or just not enjoying that part of the game. Those call for different fixes.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
critconfirmKid:
A small card saying what to add to each common roll could help more than another rules summary.