I'm looking for tabletop RPGs where magic usually does what you want, but casting it can bring unpredictable twists or consequences. Something closer to Dungeon Crawl Classics than a system where spells simply have a known cost. What else fits?
What RPGs make casting spells unpredictable and dangerous?
Answers
Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay is worth a look. Depending on the edition, casting can trigger miscasts with effects ranging from inconvenient to genuinely nasty. The spells aren't just a resource you spend safely, and the setting treats magic as dangerous stuff.
Check the edition before buying, though. The casting rules and how often things go wrong differ between them.
Reply to this answer
Try Warhammer 40,000: Dark Heresy if a grim science fiction setting works for you. Psykers can draw on their powers for useful effects, but the psychic phenomena and perils rules can turn a roll into a much bigger problem for the whole group.
Reply to this answer
Dungeon Crawl Classics itself has a lot of variety in this department. Different spells have their own results based on the casting roll, and bad rolls can lead to corruption or other trouble. If you've only seen the core options, it's worth looking at the spell and patron rules in more detail.
Reply to this answer
For a different flavor, take a look at Mage: The Ascension. Reality can push back against magic through Paradox, particularly when the effect is overt. It's less of a spell-by-spell random mishap machine and more about deciding how much risk you're taking by bending reality in public.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Dpad.Weatherproof:
That distinction matters here. Paradox can produce unpredictable consequences, but the risk is tied to how the magic is used rather than every spell necessarily coming with a twist.