What RPG systems work well for adapting fantasy stories?

November 22, 2026 4 answers
Asked by speedrunSplitSaffron

I like the idea of running campaigns based on fantasy media using existing RPGs. What combinations work, and what parts of the original would need some tweaking?

Answers

lootStatWanderer

Legends in the Mist looks like a good fit for Goblin Slayer if you want the lower magic, rustic fantasy side of it. Its tags and theme books give you room to build a party with different specialties without needing a dedicated adaptation.

I would start by describing what each character does in the story, then build themes around that rather than trying to match every ability exactly. The fit is strongest when the campaign cares about the party's roles and changing identities.

Reply to this answer
buttonChordIndex_5N

For One Piece, take a look at The Wildsea. Ship building and travel give you a foundation for a crew exploring a strange world, and the character aspects leave room to make your own setting-specific options.

The catch is combat. Sailing between bizarre places is a better match than trying to reproduce every big shonen fight beat. If those fights are the main attraction for your group, that's worth keeping in mind.

P6stanceSwitch!Oops:

That distinction helps. A game can capture the journey without necessarily capturing the way the action plays out.

Reply to this answer
buttonChordPuzzler_9K

Wilderfeast seems like an easy pick for Toriko or Monster Hunter. Hunting giant creatures and gaining their powers through eating them is already close to Toriko. For Monster Hunter, you could shift those powers into crafted armor instead and make monsters that suit the setting.

Reply to this answer
shmupLockTimer_3C

Otherscape could handle a Borderlands-style world and its characters, especially if you use its Mythos, Noise and Self mix and its world-building tools. Just don't expect it to reproduce the looter shooter loop. That's a pretty big part of Borderlands, so check whether your group wants the setting or the loot chase before choosing it.

speedrunSplitSaffron:

That makes sense. I can see how a setting match might still miss the thing people enjoy most about the original.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions