I’m looking for resolution systems that keep the GM from having to invent a complication or extra benefit after every roll. Straight success or failure seems useful, as do moves with specific results. What else should I look for?
What RPG mechanics require less interpretation after each roll?
Answers
Look for task rolls where the intended result is agreed before the dice hit the table. On a success, the task happens. On a failure, it doesn’t. You can still describe the outcome, but you don’t have to come up with a fresh twist every time.
That doesn’t remove all GM judgment. Someone still has to decide whether a roll is needed and how difficult the task is. It just makes the result easier to apply.
Reply to this answer
Defined moves are worth a look, but check the actual move text rather than just counting outcome tiers. A move that gives you specific choices or consequences on a partial success does more work for you than one that says success comes with a complication.
Apocalypse World has defined moves, though some weaker results and misses still call for interpretation. The amount of work can vary from move to move.
Reply to this answer
I’d separate deciding the stakes from interpreting the result. If a roll is specifically about avoiding danger, the GM may need to identify that danger before the roll. That can make the outcome clear afterward, but it still takes some creative effort for each situation.
Reply to this answer
Watch out for generic degrees of success too. A result of extra success sounds straightforward until someone has to decide what extra means for climbing a wall, persuading a guard, or fixing a machine. A system with concrete effects for each degree will give the GM less to invent than one that leaves those effects open.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
QTEpromptBySpoon:
That distinction helps. I’m interested in reducing the total work around the roll, not just the work after it.