What might be missing from a big TTRPG library?

November 13, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P1_sidejob

I'm helping manage a library of more than 400 tabletop RPG books, mostly modern games still in print. We can add a few books each quarter, but I want to spot gaps in the collection rather than just buy more supplements.

What kinds of core books or reference materials would you look for, and how would you organize the shelves so people can find something they want to play?

Answers

patchDiff42

Start with playability. For each game on the shelf, check whether the collection has the books needed to run it, not just attractive setting books and expansions. A core rulebook may cover everything, but some games split player rules, game master guidance and creatures across separate volumes.

I'd also note the edition beside each entry. A shelf full of supplements is less useful if the matching core book is missing or the editions don't line up.

Reply to this answer
pocketComboist

Look for gaps in what people can play, not just gaps in publishers. Fantasy, horror, science fiction, mystery and historical games offer different starting points. Then look at how they play: rules-heavy tactical games, lighter narrative games, one-shots and longer campaigns.

Those categories overlap, so a simple catalog with multiple tags will tell you more than trying to make every book fit one neat shelf.

P1_sidejob:

That makes sense. I was thinking mostly about mechanics, but genre would probably be easier for someone browsing for their first game.

Reply to this answer
P2_trailmix

I'd keep each game together on the shelf and use the catalog for mechanics. A game can share features with several systems, and people may know its title without knowing what dice it uses.

Record the title, edition, publisher, system or mechanics, genre and book type. A short note on whether it's a complete game or a supplement would make recommendations much easier.

scrimOnMute:

Leaving room between sections could help too, especially if new purchases are arriving regularly.

Reply to this answer
inputMux7

Don't overlook material that helps people actually get a game going. Introductory adventures, quick-start rules and game master references can be more useful to a new group than another setting guide. Check what's already included with the core books before buying extras, though.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions