I keep hearing that Dungeons and Dragons 5e puts a lot of work on the GM. What does that work actually involve, and how do other systems handle it differently?
What makes some RPGs more work for the GM than others?
Answers
Workload isn't just the hours spent preparing. There's also the stuff you have to figure out while everyone is waiting: interpreting rules, choosing enemy actions, tracking conditions, and deciding what happens when players go somewhere unexpected.
A game can need very little written prep but demand a lot of improvisation. Another might take more planning up front and run smoothly once play starts. Those are different kinds of work, and people don't always dislike the same one.
Reply to this answer
In 5e, combat can be a big part of the job. The GM usually picks and runs multiple creatures, tracks their abilities and hit points, and makes judgment calls about encounters. Building an encounter that feels right can take more thought than just adding up the numbers.
That doesn't mean every session has to be meticulously balanced. A published adventure or simpler monsters can cut down the preparation, though the GM still has to run whatever shows up at the table.
Reply to this answer
Powered by the Apocalypse games often take a different approach. Many give the GM specific principles and moves for responding to the players, rather than asking for a plotted sequence of encounters. Player-facing moves also help determine when the rules kick in and what kinds of outcomes follow.
That can make preparation lighter, but it doesn't remove the GM's job. You still need to pay attention, make interesting decisions and build on what the players do. If you prefer having everything mapped out beforehand, that style might feel harder rather than easier.
Reply to this answer
Also look at who gets to create the setting and the situation. Some games explicitly ask players questions about the world or tie their characters together during setup. That's less material the GM has to invent alone, although someone still has to bring those ideas into play.
CRT_Patchbay:
That's worth checking with the group too. Not everyone wants the same amount of say in worldbuilding.
Reply to this answer
When comparing games, check the actual GM tools, not just the length of the rulebook. Useful things might include quick ways to make opponents, random tables, clear procedures for exploring, or guidance on what to do when a roll goes badly. Different tools solve different problems.
I'd pick the part of GMing you find most tiring first, then look for a game that supports that part. A lighter ruleset won't automatically help if what you really want is more help coming up with situations.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
rogueish_14:
That distinction helps. A game that reduces prep wouldn't necessarily be easier for someone who dislikes improvising.