Instead of only keeping avoided players off your team, could Dota+ have an option to put them on the opposing team when you're both searching? A grudge match sounds fun, but would it create problems for matchmaking?
What if Dota+ could put avoided players on the enemy team?
Answers
I like it as an optional setting. If someone ruined a match, getting a chance to play against them sounds a lot more satisfying than just hoping the avoid list keeps them away.
I'd make it a preference rather than a guarantee. The matchmaker could use it when both players are already suitable for the same game, without holding up a search just to force the matchup.
Reply to this answer
I'd rather keep avoiding and seeking revenge separate. Someone might avoid a player because they don't want to deal with them at all, not because they want another game with them on the other side.
A separate grudge option could work, but it shouldn't change what the existing avoid button means.
Reply to this answer
The list limit seems like the bigger issue to me. If old entries get pushed off, you can end up matched with someone you still wanted to avoid. A longer list or entries that expire after a set period, like a year, would be more useful than an enemy team preference.
quicklootByLadle:
An expiry would at least clear out old entries automatically, though a fixed year might be too long or too short depending on the player.
Reply to this answer
There's a matchmaking tradeoff here. Every preference about who can be on which team adds another constraint alongside finding a suitable match. If lots of players use it, the system may have fewer workable combinations.
I'd keep the enemy placement optional and let normal matchmaking override it when necessary. Otherwise a fun feature could make queues or match quality worse.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
deckJockey.OffHours:
Yeah, a preference is closer to what I had in mind. No need to wait around for one particular player.