What games let players invent their own powers from scratch?

November 3, 2026 5 answers
Asked by mildcombo

I am looking for games with no fixed lists of spells, feats, or abilities, or at least very little of that. Ideally the game gives you strong guidelines for making your own powers, and maybe even your own class if classes exist at all.

I am also interested in games where these things are negotiated during play instead of picked from a menu, as long as there are clear rules for doing it. It would be great if the same system also helps with monster creation and encounter design.

Answers

z3nshift

If you want the closest thing to a true blank slate, look at systems built around freeform powers or descriptors instead of fixed spell lists. Games in the superhero and cinematic fantasy space often do this better than traditional fantasy games, because the whole point is to define what a power does, then price it or limit it with tags, dice, or narrative permission.

The big thing to watch for is whether the game gives you a vocabulary for building effects. If it has a short menu of effect types, modifiers, ranges, and costs, that is usually enough to make almost anything without forcing you to compare it against an existing spell catalog. For your monster and encounter request, systems with point budgets or trait-based creation tend to handle that better than class-and-level games, because enemies are built from the same parts as PCs.

glitchpan:

That sounds closer to what I want. I mostly want the creative process to start from the idea, not from reverse-engineering a list.

Reply to this answer
turbowisp

You may have better luck with narrative games than with crunchy RPGs. In a lot of them, the character sheet is really just a list of permissions, and you describe the actual effect in play. Instead of choosing a spell called fireball, you might have a broad ability like pyromancy or command over destruction, then work out what that means in the scene with the group.

The downside is that these games often do not care much about balanced monster math in the traditional sense. They can still support adversaries and hazards, but it may be more about fictional positioning than exact stat block engineering. If monster building is a must, you probably want a game that sits somewhere between narrative and tactical design, not one that is fully freeform.

mildcombo:

That tradeoff makes sense. I can live with lighter combat math if the power creation itself is really open.

Reply to this answer
plushbyte

One route is to look at games with modular magic or powers built from verbs and parameters. Those systems usually let you combine a base effect with range, duration, area, scale, or special conditions. They are not always completely blank, but they get much closer than a spell list does because the game is asking you to assemble effects rather than pick from prewritten ones.

For your criteria, I would prioritize games that also include construction rules for NPCs and threats. If there is a chapter for designing enemies by role, threat level, or point value, that is a good sign. If the game only has player-side invention and leaves the GM to improvise everything else, it may not satisfy the full package you are after.

racketeer:

The GM tools part is a big deal for me too. I do not want to end up with a system that is open for players but vague for encounter design.

Reply to this answer
VANTAGE+

You might want to check out older schoolless or classless systems that lean on skills, advantages, and custom traits instead of prebuilt powers. Some of them let you write up almost anything as long as the table agrees on the mechanics and point cost. They are not always as polished as modern games, but they can be very good for the sort of improvisational power design you want.

The catch is that balance can get weird fast if the game does not have strong creation rules. The best ones usually solve that by limiting what counts as a power, or by making everything follow the same cost formula. If the game has no spell list and also no clear structure, you may just be moving the burden from the book to the table.

oakwired:

That is a helpful warning. I am fine with rules weight, but I want the system to do the heavy lifting instead of the group constantly arguing over edge cases.

Reply to this answer
murmurpad

If I were narrowing this down, I would separate your search into two buckets. First are games with true build-your-own powers, where the rules are basically a toolkit. Second are games where powers are negotiated fiction first, with mechanical support only when needed. The first bucket is better if you want consistency and GM-facing tools. The second is better if you want maximum creativity and do not mind less structure.

From what you described, the first bucket sounds like the safer fit. Games in that space usually have some kind of effect system, point-buy design, or trait construction rules for both PCs and monsters. I would avoid anything that calls itself a spell list plus customization, because that usually still has the same core problem you mentioned, where every new spell is measured against a catalog that already exists.

mildcombo:

Yeah, that split is exactly how I am thinking about it. I am leaning toward toolkit-style systems now.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions