I like the d100 system in Call of Cthulhu, but its Sanity mechanics don't really appeal to me. What does Rivers of London offer as an alternative, especially if I'm unfamiliar with the books?
What does Rivers of London offer over Call of Cthulhu?
Answers
The biggest difference is what kind of investigation you're signing up for. Rivers of London is modern urban fantasy with supernatural mysteries, magic and police work. Call of Cthulhu is built around investigating horror, often with the investigators confronting things they can't safely understand or control.
So Rivers might be the better fit if you want a strange case to investigate without making cosmic dread the whole point. The shared d100 roots don't mean the games are aiming for the same mood.
Reply to this answer
If Sanity is the sticking point, Rivers of London is worth a look. It doesn't use Call of Cthulhu's Sanity system, though magic still comes with risks. That's a pretty different proposition from a game where exposure to the unnatural can steadily wear an investigator down.
Reply to this answer
I'd also consider the setting before buying. Rivers of London draws on a specific fictional world, so you're getting more than a generic modern mystery toolkit. You don't need to know the novels to see whether supernatural investigations in that world sound fun, but setting material is part of what you're paying for.
Reply to this answer
Don't pick it just because both games use percentile rolls. Think about the campaign you want to run. If the group wants horror and a sense of vulnerability, Call of Cthulhu is an obvious choice. If they want investigators who can engage with magic in a modern setting, Rivers of London is the more natural starting point.
For a buying decision, I'd check how much of the bundle is rules versus setting and adventures, then decide whether that material is useful to your group.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
scrimSub_4V:
That's the distinction I was hoping for. I don't mind consequences, just not that particular approach to them.