What could a successor to the FV4005 Stage II even look like?

November 3, 2026 5 answers
Asked by gearcrumb

Some tank lines clearly run out of real historical successors, and the FV4005 Stage II feels like one of those cases. If you wanted a next step that keeps the same weird British glass cannon identity without just making the gun bigger again, what would actually make sense?

The idea I’m trying to work through is a transitional vehicle with a similar playstyle, maybe a hybrid with another turreted British design and some kind of deployable support feature. But I’m not sure whether that would feel like a real progression or just a random fictional step.

Answers

mellowqueue

If you want it to feel like a successor and not just a reskin, the biggest thing is to shift the role a little. The FV4005 is already basically peak dumb alpha, so a follow-up probably should not just chase more damage. Better accuracy, faster aiming, or better handling while set up would feel more believable than slapping on an even bigger cannon.

A deployable spade or dug-in mode actually fits the line pretty well, because it gives the vehicle a reason to stop and snipe instead of trying to brawl. That also helps separate it from pure fantasy tanks. Keep the armor bad, keep the silhouette huge, but give it a practical niche as a prepared firing platform.

V1ctoryLark:

Yeah, that was the main thought, something that rewards positioning instead of just escalating damage forever. I was worried the special mode might feel gimmicky though.

Reply to this answer
sidestash

The cleaner answer is probably that there is no true successor, so any new vehicle has to be a loose continuation rather than a direct one. British postwar design has plenty of oddities, but not many that naturally lead from a giant open-turret gun tank into something newer and still recognizably related.

If you build one anyway, I’d lean into a chassis that is more mobile and a turret that is a refinement rather than an escalation. Think less about “what is the next super gun” and more about “what vehicle would a designer actually try after learning the previous concept was too clumsy.” That makes the concept feel more grounded, even if it is fictional.

gearcrumb:

That is kind of the problem I keep running into. If the next step is just more gun, it stops feeling like a line and starts feeling like fan fiction.

Reply to this answer
pingcinder

I think the best version would be something that changes the shooting rhythm. A static damage monster is already covered, so a successor could trade a bit of alpha for better snap between shots, improved gun depression, or a short setup bonus when parked. That keeps the “big British gun” feeling without making it a pure one-trick cannon.

Honestly, the name and silhouette matter less than whether the mechanics explain why it exists. If it is supposed to be the step after the FV4005, then it should solve one of that tank’s obvious problems, like sluggishness or poor gun comfort, instead of doubling down on the same flaws.

Reply to this answer
r4mpshot

From a design standpoint, a hybrid with a Conway-style layout makes more sense than trying to force a pure continuation of the FV4005 turret. The open-topped, oversized turret concept is already at the edge of credibility, so a slightly more conventional turret and a better chassis would feel like a believable evolution.

I would also be careful with the special mechanic. A bonus to accuracy when deployed sounds fine, but if it becomes too strong it turns the tank into a camping machine. The sweet spot would be something small enough that it matters, but not so much that the whole vehicle becomes defined by one button.

Reply to this answer
notchpilot

If the goal is to keep the line fun, the answer may be to accept a bit of nonsense. Not every “successor” has to be a museum-grade historical link. A fictional intermediate tank can still work if it preserves the flavor, which in this case is a huge gun, bad armor, and the feeling that the crew is gambling every time they fire.

That said, I would not go for pure bigger-is-better design. A more accurate gun, slightly better mobility, and a setup bonus from a rear spade gives the vehicle a distinct identity. It feels like an attempt to make the concept practical instead of just louder.

starlit_pad:

That balance sounds right to me too. The line needs a reason to exist beyond “same tank, higher number.”

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions