I've seen a mixed review of Mythic Bastionland that praises its rules and combat but also describes struggling with the systems during a campaign. What can that kind of experience tell us about the game's design and what a table expects from it?
What can running Mythic Bastionland wrong tell you about the game?
Answers
The useful question is not just whether someone followed the rules. It's what they expected the rules to help them do. A game can be elegant and still push against the kind of campaign a group wants to run.
In this case, the tension seems to involve exploration. Meaningful travel choices need places to feel different, but filling a map takes work. Prepared material saves some of that work, while random material can be harder to fit into a coherent story. Those tradeoffs are worth discussing separately from whether the sessions were fun.
Reply to this answer
I'd be careful with the phrase running it wrong. The supplied review praises the resource management and fast, tactical combat, then starts explaining a concern about stocking a map. It cuts off before fully explaining how the Myths address that concern, so there's not enough here to diagnose a rules mistake.
That's still a useful review. Enjoyment and friction can coexist, and a criticism doesn't have to cancel out the good parts.
Reply to this answer
Table expectations matter a lot here. Does the group want a world where travel choices are informed by distinct places, or are they happy discovering what comes up along the way? Those can lead to very different reactions to generated content.
Before starting, I'd talk about how much preparation the person running the game wants to do and how much randomness the group enjoys. That won't settle whether the design works, but it gives you a better idea of whether it fits your table.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
walljump_6F:
And a prepared exploration map is another option, though its particular setting and material may not appeal to every group.