What are some mystery games with real gameplay that stream well on Discord?

November 4, 2026 5 answers
Asked by questwrench

My friend and I have a long-running nightly thing where I stream games to him for a couple of hours before bed. We both really like mystery games, especially visual novels with puzzles, investigation, or deduction, but we are open to other genres if they are fun to watch and discuss.

We have already gone through a lot of the obvious picks, including several big detective and puzzle series, so we are looking for hidden gems, indie games, or even good fan-made projects. The main thing is that it should have engaging story progression and enough gameplay to keep us talking and theorizing while we play.

Any recommendations that fit that kind of vibe?

Answers

grindmote

If you both like deduction-heavy stuff, I’d look at Return of the Obra Dinn, The Case of the Golden Idol, and The Rise of the Golden Idol. They all do that nice thing where the game gives you a set of clues and asks you to actually piece the answer together instead of just clicking through dialogue.

Her Story and Immortality are also good for stream-style discussion because you end up building theories out loud as you search through fragments. If you want something a little different but still mystery-first, The Forgotten City is strong too. It is less of a pure puzzle box, more of a story-driven investigation with a lot of branching guesses and loop-based trial and error.

z3nmode:

Obra Dinn especially sounds like the exact kind of thing we’d spend ages arguing over in a good way. We have somehow missed the Golden Idol games too, so those are going on the list.

Reply to this answer
HUDpilot

Since you already cleared a lot of the obvious visual novel and adventure picks, I’d throw in some weirder narrative games that still give you something to do. The Painscreek Killings is a standout if you want a real investigation game where you roam, read, compare notes, and slowly build the case yourself. It is very light on handholding.

Another one is Return to Grace, which is more sci-fi mystery than full puzzle game, but it has a strong premise and enough exploration to keep a stream moving. If you are okay with older or rougher edges, The House of Fata Morgana is also worth looking at, although it leans much harder into story than mechanics. Still, for a long-form mystery session, it can absolutely hook people.

questwrench:

The Painscreek Killings sounds especially promising because we do like games that just let us poke around and figure things out ourselves. Thanks, that’s exactly the kind of recommendation I was hoping for.

Reply to this answer
tanglebyte

If the stream is part of the fun, I’d consider games that are chaotic to discuss rather than just strictly puzzle-based. Shadows of Doubt is a great fit because it turns detective work into a procedural sandbox. You gather clues, track routines, and try to connect the dots, so every case has a bit of improvised storytelling.

For something with a similar “we are solving this together” energy, I’d also mention Contradiction: Spot the Liar, Murder by Numbers, and Detective Grimoire. They are a little lighter and sometimes sillier, but they still keep both players engaged because there is always another clue or contradiction to chase.

arcskip:

Shadows of Doubt is a really interesting angle. We usually gravitate toward hand-crafted mysteries, but a procedural detective game could be a nice change of pace for us.

mellowcrank:

And Murder by Numbers looks cute in a way that might help break up all the heavier long mysteries we’ve been doing. Nice call.

Reply to this answer
hexraider

For more obscure visual novel territory, I’d point you toward Raging Loop, Chaos;Child, and the Science Adventure games in general if you have not already tried them all. They are less puzzle-driven than Ace Attorney or Zero Escape, but they do a very good job of keeping the mystery layer active, and the reveals tend to land well when you are discussing them live.

Another route is mystery-adjacent horror with choices and exploration, like Oxenfree, Inscryption, or Scarlet Hollow. They are not detective games in the strict sense, but they are excellent for a shared stream because they constantly feed you new questions, odd details, and “wait, what is going on here” moments.

Reply to this answer
kickerloop

If you are okay with fan projects, the safest bets are usually the ones built around a familiar series structure, like Ace Attorney or Danganronpa style case design. The quality varies a lot, though, so I’d screen them a bit before committing to a long nightly run. Some are clever and well paced, while others are basically just references wrapped around a mystery.

For a more dependable fallback, I’d say look at shorter mystery games that are meant to be finished in a few sessions. That makes them easier to slot into a two-hour nightly routine without the momentum dying out. Games with strong chapter breaks, case files, or looping structures tend to work best for that kind of stream.

questwrench:

That makes sense. We do better with games that have clean session breakpoints, so I’ll probably prioritize shorter structured mysteries after the longer epics we’ve already done.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions