Should Xbox reviews show how long someone has played?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by LANguest.EarlyBird

Could verified playtime on Xbox reviews help people judge whether a rating is based on the game itself? Would showing the hours be enough, or should there be a minimum playtime before someone can review?

Answers

mechMissileRack_4Q

Showing playtime when the review was posted seems like the simplest option. Readers could decide for themselves whether a few minutes, a few hours, or a full playthrough gives the review enough context.

It wouldn't prove the person paid attention or that their criticism is fair, but it would make a rating from someone who barely opened the game easier to spot.

P8guardPoint_3R:

The timestamp matters too. Someone might play more after posting, so their current total wouldn't necessarily reflect what they knew when they reviewed it.

Reply to this answer
rogueSkillBudget_4C

I'd be wary of a five hour minimum. Some games are short, and a game that crashes or has serious problems right away could deserve a review before that point. Displaying the time gives useful context without blocking those reviews.

Reply to this answer
mechPilot_Quietly

A playtime requirement might make a low-effort rating campaign more inconvenient, but it isn't a reliable way to tell why someone left a rating. A person can have hours recorded and still review a game for reasons unrelated to playing it.

I'd treat verified time as one signal, not a verdict on whether a review is genuine.

Reply to this answer
DOSbeepSequence+Rhubarb

The access method shouldn't be the deciding factor. Someone playing through Game Pass can have just as much useful feedback as someone who bought the game. What matters for this idea is whether the account has actually played, not how it got access.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions