Should Xbox be investing more in id Tech?

November 19, 2026 3 answers
Asked by critRate.Offline

id Tech looks impressive in MachineGames titles, so why isn't Microsoft putting more resources into it? How should engine investment fit with support for its studios, especially when staff cuts are involved?

Answers

lootBudget~Casual

The case for investing in it is pretty straightforward. A strong internal engine could give Xbox studios useful technology to build on, and MachineGames shows that id Tech can produce impressive results outside id's own games.

That doesn't mean every studio should be pushed onto it. Different games have different needs, and adapting an engine, training teams, and maintaining tools all take resources. I'd rather see Microsoft support the teams that use it well than force it everywhere.

Reply to this answer
shmupOneCredit

Staff cuts are a fair reason to question the strategy. An engine isn't just a piece of software sitting on a shelf. The people who maintain it and help game teams use it matter too. But without knowing the internal plans, it's hard to say exactly what the cuts mean for id Tech.

Reply to this answer
P2controller.7N

I wouldn't assume it should be an Unreal competitor just because a game made with it looks great. Competing as a widely used engine would also mean supporting a lot of different developers, tools, and types of games. Microsoft might decide it's more useful as technology for particular studios than as an engine for everyone.

GBAtraceByBiscuit:

That distinction matters. A great engine for a few teams isn't automatically a good fit for every project.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions