Close-range torpedo damage is reduced, which can make underwater sub fights feel like a stalemate. Would restoring full damage only against other submarines make those fights better without affecting surface ships?
Should submarines get full torpedo damage against other subs at close range?
Answers
That sounds worth trying. If two subs spot each other at short range, they should have a way to settle the fight instead of waiting for teammates to drop depth charges. Keeping the change limited to sub targets avoids bringing back the same close-range threat against surface ships.
Reply to this answer
Full damage might make those encounters more decisive, but that is not automatically the same as making them better. If spotting first lets one sub land a devastating hit before the other can respond, the fight could end up feeling even less interactive.
I'd rather see how often subs can detect and react to each other at those ranges before picking a damage number.
Reply to this answer
Damage isn't the whole problem. Some subs may have trouble using their homing torpedoes effectively in a close duel, even when their surveillance can reveal the other sub. A damage change alone might help some boats much more than others.
Reply to this answer
I like the sub versus sub restriction, but I wouldn't assume it leaves surface ships unaffected in practice. If subs spend more time hunting each other, that changes where they are and what they're doing, even if their torpedo damage against surface targets stays exactly the same.
parryWindow+Cupcake:
That's fair. I meant keeping the damage against surface ships unchanged, not that their matches would play out identically.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
manaCurve+Colander:
It could also make positioning matter more when deciding whether to push toward an enemy sub.