When someone queues as a support or offlaner but plays like another carry, it can make the match rough for everyone else. Would losing extra role queue games be a fair penalty, or would that be too easy to abuse?
Should role abuse cost players extra role queue games?
Answers
A small role queue penalty makes sense to me. If someone earns games by queuing for a role and then ignores that role, taking away an extra queued game directly targets the benefit they got from it.
It could scale with the number of reports, but I would want some kind of review before applying it. Two teammates reporting someone doesn't automatically prove they were abusing their role.
Reply to this answer
The hard part is deciding what counts. Dota roles are flexible, and an unusual pick or greedy item build isn't necessarily griefing. A support who spends the whole game farming jungle while ignoring the team is a clearer case than a support who buys one damage item.
I'd rather punish the actual behavior than make a rule based on the hero or build alone.
Reply to this answer
Automatic penalties from two reports sound risky. Teammates can disagree about how a lane should be played, and a losing game can make people look for someone to blame. Reports should flag a match for review, not be the whole verdict.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P11~LoadoutLint:
That distinction makes sense. An unconventional support can still be playing support, while someone who abandons the role entirely is another matter.