Should old weapons be easier to farm directly instead of waiting on huge random pools?

November 5, 2026 5 answers
Asked by lanesnack

Some players want a cleaner way to get specific older weapons and armor instead of relying on giant loot pools with weak odds. Ideas range from a focused vendor pool to letting collections or special drops cover older gear.

What would be a fair deterministic system for target farming without making everything too easy?

Answers

VEXM0D

The simplest fix is a rotating focused pool. Put a limited set of older items on a vendor each week, then let players spend materials to pick the exact weapon slot or armor piece. That keeps the chase alive, but cuts out the nonsense where one specific drop is buried under a mountain of junk.

If they want to avoid flooding the game, they can separate it by source. World loot stays random, but retired or hard-to-find gear gets a dedicated path. That feels way better than hoping the right item shows up in a huge generic pool.

twitchloom:

Yeah, and the rotation could be small enough that you still have to check back regularly. It does not need to be instant access to everything, just predictable enough that collectors are not stuck forever.

Reply to this answer
h4ndbrake

I would go more aggressive and say collections should matter more. If you have already earned the item once, let collections give you a rerollable version or a curated random roll from a limited perk list. That would solve a lot of the old gear problem without handing out perfect drops for free.

The big upside is that it rewards actually having found the item before. The downside is balance, because if the perk pools are too loose then the old chase disappears. So the trick is to make the rerolls useful, but not identical to a full custom craft system.

lanesnack:

That sounds close to a middle ground. The main thing I want is some path that does not depend on luck over luck over luck.

Reply to this answer
mellowbyte

Honestly, some of these items should just be placed in a legacy kiosk or vendor with a clear cost. Not everything needs a full farming loop. If a weapon is effectively out of circulation, making people pray to random drops does not add much value.

I think the best split is this. New gear can stay random or craftable, while retired gear gets deterministic access. That way veterans still have something to chase on current content, and collectors are not punished for wanting old favorites.

quillpanic:

The retired gear distinction makes a lot of sense. It keeps the current grind intact without turning old items into a museum exhibit that nobody can reliably get.

Reply to this answer
SPL1Tplay

There is a danger in making everything deterministic, because then vendors become shopping lists and loot stops feeling like loot. But the current massive pool model is too far the other way. A good compromise is targeted engrams with narrow loot tables that get narrower the more you focus them.

For example, first you pick a weapon family, then a specific archetype, then maybe a perk bias. That still leaves room for randomness, but the player is steering the outcome instead of begging for it. It also works for armor, where players usually care more about stat distribution than a fully random mystery roll.

emberdash:

That tiered focusing idea is probably the cleanest system. It gives progression at every step instead of all-or-nothing gambling.

Reply to this answer
cinderpocket

If the goal is collector access, I would even be okay with old items dropping from a separate legacy source at a much higher rate, as long as the source is obvious and repeatable. The key is clarity. Players should know where to go, what can drop there, and what the odds roughly feel like.

What gets frustrating is when an item is technically still in the game but effectively buried so deep that nobody can reasonably target it. A predictable route, even if it costs more, is better than pretending the item is available through random chance alone.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions