A Classic queue could bring back an early version of League, but a lot of the appeal might be playing champions as they were before major reworks. Would you prefer one stable S3 to S6 style patch, or rotating patches with each era's roster?
Should League Classic focus on S3 to S6 champions instead of S1?
Answers
I'd take a stable S3 to S6 style patch. Old Swain, stance based Udyr and short range Graves are the kinds of champion versions that give the mode a reason to exist. A strict S1 roster would leave out players who came back for a later version of the game.
It doesn't have to recreate every patch from those seasons. Pick a coherent version and let people get familiar with it.
Reply to this answer
Rotating eras sounds more interesting to me. S3 through S6 covers several seasons, so picking one fixed version still means leaving out some champion designs people remember. Rotations would give more of those versions a chance without pretending they all belong to the same patch.
Reply to this answer
There's a difference between a historical patch and a greatest hits roster. If you mix old champion versions from different seasons, you also have to decide which items, systems and balance numbers they play with. That could be fun, but it wouldn't be a straightforward recreation of any one era.
I'd rather see a complete era picked first, roster and all, so the rules of the mode make sense together.
Reply to this answer
I can see the case for starting with S1. An early version has its own identity, even if it doesn't include every champion someone wants. Later eras could still be explored separately rather than trying to make the first version satisfy everyone.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
mechPilot_Offline:
That would cover more ground, though I wonder whether frequent changes would make it harder to settle on a main.