Should I get the Etrian Odyssey HD collection or play the originals?

November 20, 2026 3 answers
Asked by quickslotTetris+Button

I’m interested in the party creation and thinking about trying the series. The HD collection is on sale, but playing the original DS games through emulation is another option. Are the remasters worth buying for the quality of life changes?

Answers

QTEtap~NotQuite

The HD collection is the more convenient place to start if you want to buy and play on a modern system. It includes remasters of the first three games, with updated visuals and interface changes. Whether that convenience is worth the sale price depends on how much you value playing an older version instead.

Reply to this answer
deckManaPouch_2V

Consider the mapping controls before deciding. The DS games were built around drawing maps on a touchscreen, so check how you’d handle that in an emulator. The HD versions also retain manual mapping, though the setup will feel different from the original hardware.

Reply to this answer
P5crossupWhiff_7J

If party creation is the main draw, you don’t necessarily need to buy all three games at once. The HD games are also sold separately, so you could start with one and see if the dungeon crawling and mapping click before committing to the collection.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions