I'm planning a password-locked diary in a sci-fi RPG. The passwords relate to people and places important to its late owner, so I want the players to engage with that history. But one character specializes in tech, and I'm worried a no-roll lock would shut them out. How would you handle it?
Should I allow rolls to bypass a puzzle lock?
Answers
Let the tech character roll, but make success reveal a useful clue rather than just opening every entry. Maybe they can find the password format, recover part of an old entry, or narrow down which personal detail matters.
That gives their specialty a real payoff while leaving the group something to investigate. Decide what the roll can reveal before calling for it, so it doesn't feel like the goalposts move afterward.
Reply to this answer
I'd let a good roll crack it outright. If the character is built to handle security, a lock that mysteriously can't be hacked may feel more contrived than a puzzle the players bypass.
The diary can still contain details that lead them into the owner's history. Solving the lock doesn't have to mean they're done engaging with the story.
Reply to this answer
No-roll puzzles can work, but give the group enough information to make educated guesses. If the password is a meaningful place, there should be a way to learn about that place during play, not just hope someone remembers an obscure detail.
Also consider what happens if they get stuck. You could have another lead point toward the answer, or allow them to revisit the diary after finding more context. Keep anything essential to the story available through another route.
Reply to this answer
Make hacking possible, but give it a cost or a complication that fits the game. It might take time, require equipment, or risk damaging an entry. Then guessing the password is an appealing option rather than the only option.
Be clear about the possible cost before the player chooses. A surprise penalty for using their character's main skill could feel pretty rough.
Reply to this answer
Check what kind of puzzle the group actually enjoys. Some players like working out passwords themselves, while others would rather say what their skilled character does and roll. You can ask about that preference without revealing what the diary contains.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
shmupContinue~OneCredit:
Multiple relevant clues could help too. Knowing both who mattered to the owner and where they spent time gives players something to reason from.