I'm new to GMing and ran a mystery session with lots of conversations and only a few rolls. The players were surprised by how little they rolled, but I don't want basic actions or clever ideas to fail just because of a bad die. Should I be asking for more rolls?
Should a mystery session have more dice rolls?
Answers
Not necessarily. A roll is useful when the outcome is genuinely uncertain and either result would change what happens next. If someone makes a convincing appeal that the listener has every reason to accept, you can just let it work.
When you do ask for a roll, think about what failure means first. A failed attempt to read someone might leave their intentions unclear, while a failed appeal might mean they want a concession before helping. It doesn't have to turn into a ridiculous disaster.
Reply to this answer
For a mystery, I'd be wary of hiding the one clue needed to move forward behind a single roll. If the characters look in the right place or ask someone who knows, give them something useful. A roll could determine how quickly they find it, how much extra detail they get, or whether they attract attention.
That still leaves plenty for the players to figure out. Finding a clue and deciding what it means are different challenges.
Reply to this answer
The surprise from your players is worth talking about. Some people enjoy dice as part of the fun, even in a mostly social session. Ask whether they wanted more uncertainty, more chances to use their characters' abilities, or just expected the game to work differently.
You don't need to add rolls to every conversation, but that discussion might reveal moments where a roll would make the scene more exciting for the group.
Reply to this answer
Check the rules of the game you're running, too. Different games put rolls in different places, and some give specific procedures for social situations or investigations. Fewer rolls can be fine, but it helps to know whether you're skipping a rule the players expected to use.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
questLogMinimalist:
It can help to tell players what's at stake before they roll, especially if failure could close off an option they care about.