Ran out of prep in my first homebrew session. What should I do differently?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by staminaBuildByMug

My first homebrew session went through most of my prep in about an hour and a half. The players avoided the fights I expected, and I had to pull material from the next session.

I'm thinking of sending them through a haunted mansion next. How can I prepare it so it's fun without running out of things to do again?

Answers

quickbar3QSpelunker

Prep the mansion as a place, not a sequence of scenes. Give it a handful of interesting rooms, a reason it's haunted, and a few things the occupants want. Then let the players decide where to poke around.

If they need an item to reach the next destination, give them more than one way to find it. They might bargain with a ghost, investigate a clue, or fight something guarding it. That way skipping a fight doesn't also skip the whole adventure.

P1safejump+Scone:

A couple of clues pointing toward the item would help too. Players can easily miss one room or interpret a clue differently than you expected.

Reply to this answer
scrimFill_9T

Don't count combat as guaranteed session time. Your group might talk, sneak, run, or avoid the encounter altogether. For each obstacle, jot down what happens if they don't fight and what the creatures or characters do next.

You don't need to predict every choice. A few names, motives, and possible complications can give you something to work with when the party goes sideways.

Reply to this answer
DOSbeep_6W

Honestly, using next session's material early is fine. The players don't know when you planned to use it. If you hit a wall, taking a short break to collect your thoughts is fine too.

Ask the group what they enjoyed and what they want more of. They reassured you, so don't assume the session felt as disastrous to them as it did to you.

Reply to this answer
GBAbootlegger!Mildly

You could borrow a published haunted house or a short adventure and change the details to fit your campaign. It gives you a ready-made layout and encounters while you get a feel for pacing.

Starting with homebrew isn't a mistake, but you also don't have to invent every room yourself.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions