Is this much RNG a reasonable way to gate endgame progression?

November 17, 2026 4 answers
Asked by MeleeOnLayaway

My Whirlwind Barbarian has strong gear, high glyph levels, and the right stats, but damage is still holding me back in the Pit. After hundreds of weapon transfigurations, I haven't found the gem strength and modifiable combination that seems like the next major upgrade.

Is this kind of rare-item hunt a good endgame mechanic, or does it make pushing higher tiers too dependent on luck?

Answers

scrimByPostcard

Random drops are fine when they give you a chance at an upgrade. They feel worse when one very specific combination becomes the only realistic way to keep progressing.

At that point, some kind of bad luck protection or gradual way to work toward the combination would make the grind feel less like wasted time. It could still be rare without leaving the result entirely to chance.

Reply to this answer
GBCreset7

I don't mind the very highest tiers being a long shot. Chasing an unusually good item can give an endgame build something to do after the easier upgrades are gone.

That said, there's a difference between an optional stretch goal and a tier the game expects most players to clear. I'd judge the randomness differently depending on which one the Pit is meant to be.

Reply to this answer
inputLag~Tamarind

Before treating the weapon as the only option, I'd double check the build's damage setup against the tier you're trying to clear. Correct stats and high glyph levels sound promising, but the details of how damage bonuses interact can still matter.

That doesn't mean there's definitely another upgrade available. It just separates a possible build issue from the question of whether the item chase itself is too punishing.

MeleeOnLayaway:

That's worth checking. The frustrating part is that the gear already looks close to finished, so it's hard to tell how much room is left elsewhere.

Reply to this answer
lootDraftingByBus

Hundreds of attempts without the combination sounds rough, but it doesn't tell us the actual odds. Without those, it's hard to say whether the chase is unusually unlucky or simply designed to take a very long time.

Clearer information about how rare the combination is would at least help players decide whether to keep farming or spend their time on something else.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions