MSI has reportedly called a firmware bug a Linux issue, while AMD engineers dispute that explanation. Two BIOS updates later, it still appears unresolved. What can be concluded from that?
Is this MSI firmware bug really a Linux issue?
Answers
Not much about the root cause yet. A disagreement between MSI and AMD engineers is a reason to keep the question open, not proof by itself that either side has identified the fault.
The fact that two BIOS updates did not fix it also does not tell us whether those updates were intended to address this particular bug.
Reply to this answer
The useful next step is a reproducible bug report: exact hardware, BIOS version, Linux distribution and kernel version, what triggers the problem, and what actually happens. Include logs if available and note whether the behavior changed after each update.
Testing another operating system could provide a comparison, but a problem showing up only on Linux would not automatically prove Linux is at fault. Firmware and operating systems interact in ways that need investigation.
Reply to this answer
For anyone deciding whether to update, check the release notes rather than assuming a newer BIOS contains a fix. If the issue remains, report the result with the new version number so support has a clear record.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBCtapeDeck:
It would also help to include the exact explanation from each vendor, if available. The distinction between a suspected cause and a confirmed diagnosis matters here.