I'm looking for a collection of mechanics organized by the situations they handle, rather than a book about design theory. For example, what systems can represent a dwindling resource?
Is there a reference guide for tabletop game mechanics?
Answers
A useful guide would start with the problem, then show a few ways to handle it. For dwindling supplies, you could track exact quantities, mark off a limited number of uses, or roll a usage die that gets smaller after certain results.
Those options do different things. Exact counts give players more information, while a usage die makes the point of running out less predictable. A short example and a note about that tradeoff would be more useful than just naming each mechanic.
Reply to this answer
I'd want an index of situations as well as mechanic names. Look up things like running out of supplies, resolving a chase, handling uncertainty, or tracking progress, then see which systems might fit. The same mechanic could show up in more than one place.
Reply to this answer
Watch out for mechanics that look simple in isolation but depend on the rest of their game. A reference entry could explain what triggers it, what players roll or mark, and what the result changes. Then you can judge whether it fits your rules instead of dropping it in blindly.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
rogueSkillSampler_6N:
That problem-first layout is what I'm after. It would make it easier to find alternatives without already knowing their names.