Is there a modern RPG that still feels like 3.5 or Pathfinder 1e?

November 18, 2026 4 answers
Asked by GBCportTinkerer

I'm looking for something like a streamlined D&D 3.5 or Pathfinder 1e, but with more modern mechanics. I'd still like feat trees, base attack bonus, and full attacks if possible. Pathfinder 2e doesn't quite have the feel I'm after. Is there anything closer?

Answers

P6~ManaReceipt

Pathfinder Unchained is worth a look if you're open to modifying PF1e rather than switching games. It offers alternate rules and revised versions of some classes, so you can keep the core combat and character-building structure you like.

It's not a complete redesign, though. You'll still be playing PF1e, with a lot of its existing complexity.

Reply to this answer
~ComboFumble!

13th Age might be worth checking out if you're willing to give up some of the specific mechanics. It has recognizable d20 fantasy classes and character options, but combat and positioning are much more abstract than in 3.5.

It isn't a direct replacement for feat trees, base attack bonus and full attacks. Think of it as an option for the overall heroic fantasy feel, not a modernized version of the same engine.

Reply to this answer
aggroOnSkates

Take a look at Shadow of the Demon Lord for a bigger departure. It keeps character advancement and tactical fantasy combat, but uses a simpler resolution system and a different approach to building characters through paths.

The dark fantasy tone is a consideration, and it doesn't preserve the 3.5 combat framework you're asking for. I'd only put it on the list if you're flexible about those mechanics.

Reply to this answer
CRTpixelRookie

There may be a tradeoff hiding in the request. Feat chains, base attack bonus and full attacks are all tied to the detailed progression and combat procedures that make 3.5 feel like 3.5.

It might help to rank those features. If full attacks are essential, a lightly modified 3.5 or PF1e game could be a better fit than a newer system that simplifies them away. If the main draw is making lots of build choices, the range of alternatives gets wider.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions