Is there a fast, heroic fantasy RPG with a bit of simulation to it?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P7blockString!Soon

I want to introduce my group to a more simulation-minded fantasy RPG in a one-shot, but they prefer pulpy heroes and worry about slow skill progression and drawn-out fights.

Is there something with less player bookkeeping, descriptive and fairly quick combat, and room to be incapacitated without dying? Hit locations would be nice but aren't essential. I'd also prefer something that doesn't rely on percentile dice.

Answers

P8jabConfirm+Okra

It sounds like combat feel is the thing to test first, rather than progression. In a one-shot, faster advancement won't come up much unless you build an improvement into the session. Give everyone capable starting characters and plan one meaningful upgrade between scenes.

For the fight, use a small number of opponents with different tactics instead of a crowd of identical enemies. That should give the group a chance to see whether they enjoy descriptive combat without making the whole session a rules exercise.

Reply to this answer
P8dashBrake!Late

Mythras itself may still be worth a look if it's the game you're excited about. The paragon character creation option could give the characters the heroic starting point you want, though that doesn't automatically make combat quick or remove the percentile dice.

For a first session, I'd keep the number of combatants down and learn the relevant rules beforehand. Run a short practice fight solo too. You'll get a better sense of the pace before asking the group to try it.

GBCsoundChipMittens:

That also makes it easier to separate dislike of percentile dice from dislike of skill-based games. They're not quite the same concern.

Reply to this answer
deckSideboardDaydream

I'd be careful about treating fast, brutal, and not very deadly as the same requirement. A game can resolve attacks quickly and still kill characters easily. Check how it handles wounds, incapacitation, and recovery before settling on it, especially if you want fights to feel dangerous without ending a character's story.

Reply to this answer
QTEthumbMambo_6R

You might have better luck asking for a specific kind of simulation rather than a lighter version of the whole package. Is the appeal hit locations, tactical choices, injuries that matter, or characters having lots of individual skills? Those can pull in different directions when you're trying to keep bookkeeping low.

For a one-shot, I'd pick the one or two features that matter most and let the rest go. Gridless play and a vivid description of a hit can do a lot for the feel even without tracking every body part.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions