Is the damage gap between Whirlwind Barbarian and Zeal Paladin really this big?

November 19, 2026 4 answers
Asked by DpadTuning!Maybe

I'm comparing two endgame builds in Diablo 4 that took roughly the same amount of time to put together. Whirlwind Barbarian crits seem to reach around 7 trillion on average, while Zeal Paladin crits are closer to 10 billion. Is that a fair way to judge the balance between them?

Answers

pixelMender!8K

Those numbers suggest a huge gap, but comparing individual crits doesn't tell you the whole damage story. The skills may hit at different rates, and average damage per hit doesn't account for noncrits, uptime, or how many targets get hit.

A better comparison would be damage over the same stretch of a boss fight, with similar gear investment and conditions. Even then, it would compare these particular builds, not every option available to either class.

DpadTuning!Maybe:

That makes sense. The crit numbers stood out, but I don't have a timed damage comparison for the two builds.

Reply to this answer
co-opQueue_Elsewhere

Equal time spent gearing doesn't necessarily mean equal build strength. One character might have found more useful gear or have more of the pieces its build needs. That doesn't make a large gap okay, but it makes the cause harder to pin down.

Reply to this answer
MUDprompt+Teakettle

If Zeal was already struggling and changes to Resolve stacks reduced its damage further, that sounds like a specific thing worth checking in the build. The comparison alone doesn't establish how much those changes contributed, though.

Reply to this answer
deckDraft!Untidy

Even allowing for hit frequency, a difference that large in displayed crits is worth investigating. A build can feel pretty rough in endgame if it takes much more investment to deal with the same content, regardless of whether the exact gap is 100 times or something else.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions