It seems like a mage can clear the wave, recall after a bad trade, and get back to lane without missing much. Does Homeguard make that too easy to do?
Is Homeguard making mage lanes too safe?
Answers
That recall pattern is the strongest argument against it. If a mage can spend their mana clearing the wave and get back quickly enough to miss very few minions, a bad trade may not create much of an opening for the opponent.
It also makes mage versus mage lanes feel less interactive when neither side can finish a kill before the other pushes and recalls.
Reply to this answer
The bigger issue might be what happens when the opponent can't force a kill. An assassin who can threaten an all-in or a dive has a way to punish the mage, but a champion without that threat may struggle to turn a good trade into an advantage.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't put the whole thing on Homeguard alone. Waveclear and how quickly a mage can recover mana at the fountain are part of the same recall pattern. If it's too forgiving, those are worth looking at alongside the speed back to lane.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
QCFmotionScribbler:
Yeah, that's the part that feels odd. Even without a cannon wave, the recall can be pretty forgiving.