Elytra makes getting around so convenient that minecarts and horses can feel hard to justify. Would it be better to improve those alternatives instead of nerfing flight?
Is Elytra really the problem with travel in Minecraft?
Answers
I think the alternatives need work first. A rail line takes a lot of materials and setup for a fixed route, while a horse can be awkward to manage over rough terrain. Neither has to beat Elytra at everything, but they should feel worthwhile in situations where flight isn't the obvious choice.
Reply to this answer
Minecarts have a problem even before Elytra enters the picture. If building a track takes ages and the payoff doesn't feel much better than travelling on foot, it's hard to justify the project. Faster carts or a more rewarding reason to build routes would help.
Reply to this answer
Horses could fill the gap for shorter trips, but handling them and dealing with terrain can make them feel like more trouble than they're worth. Making them easier to manage would give players a reason to use them without turning them into another version of flight.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't take a nerf completely off the table, but I'd look at why the other options feel bad first. Improving rails and horses might make the choice more interesting without taking away the travel method people already enjoy.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBCtilePuzzler+Pesto:
Yeah, I like the idea of each option having a reason to exist rather than just making flight less fun.