I'm interested in Echoes of Aincrad, but the review scores seem mixed. Does it sound worthwhile for fans of Sword Art Online, and how well does it work for newcomers?
Is Echoes of Aincrad worth buying based on the reviews?
Answers
It sounds like a better bet if you're already attached to Sword Art Online and want another visit to Aincrad. One review found it charming and faithful to that world, while cautioning that newcomers shouldn't expect it to reinvent the genre.
Reply to this answer
The main tradeoff is combat versus exploration. One critic enjoyed the fighting, upgrades, and crafting, but found the levels very linear and the missions repetitive. If wandering around and finding things is a big part of the appeal for you, that criticism would give me pause.
Reply to this answer
The story got some praise for staying fairly serious through much of the adventure. That same review felt it eventually leaned on familiar save-the-world clichés, though, and that the protagonist was sidelined. So even the stronger narrative impressions came with caveats.
Reply to this answer
The roundup listed a 66 average and a 44% recommendation rate across 25 reviews. That's a mixed snapshot, not a verdict on whether you'll enjoy it. Given the concerns about repetitive missions, waiting for a sale seems reasonable unless the setting itself is a big draw.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions