How would you pick a Dota lineup for a football manager game?

November 18, 2026 4 answers
Asked by GBAportTassel

I'm curious how Dota abilities might translate into football tactics. Which heroes would you pick, and how would you handle abilities that deal damage?

Answers

queueMuffler26

Arc Warden in goal is a fun starting point. If Magnetic Field makes shots miss, opponents would have to find a way to carry the ball into the protected area. That gives the rest of the team a clear job: stop them getting close.

The big question is whether the field actually affects a football. I'd agree on that before treating him as an unbeatable keeper, especially for penalties.

RNGrollByTrolley:

And what happens when the field isn't active? That could make a big difference to how much cover the keeper needs.

Reply to this answer
comboWindow_3F

Earthshaker and Disruptor make an interesting centre back pairing for a high line. Fissure could channel attacks into crowded areas, while Disruptor could help deal with runners getting behind the defence. The idea is to control where the other team can play, not just chase the ball.

Clockwerk at right back could stay deeper when the team has possession, giving you a back three. His cogs could also make life awkward for a winger, though the damaging parts need a ruling.

Reply to this answer
GBAcart~Thimble

Batrider at left back is a strange pick, but it makes sense if he moves into midfield when the team has the ball. Sticky Napalm could make opponents slower to turn, giving the defensive midfielder some help. That side would still need cover if possession is lost.

Reply to this answer
lootCache47

Set the foul rules first or the lineup debate gets messy fast. One possible house rule is that more than 150 damage counts as a foul, more than 500 damage or 30% of health earns a yellow, and more than 800 damage or 50% earns a red. Zero health means an injury.

Then decide whether repeated low damage adds up. That matters for spells like Ice Path and for Clockwerk's Battery Assault. It's a made-up ruleset, so the numbers don't have to be perfect, just clear enough that both teams can build around them.

GBAportTassel:

Adding up repeated damage makes sense. Otherwise a low-damage ability could be used over and over without a foul.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions