I've seen the number 2^64 for Minecraft seeds, but terrain and structures have changed across updates and editions. Does that mean the total number of possible worlds is much bigger?
How many Minecraft worlds are possible if generation keeps changing?
Answers
2^64 is the number of possible values for a 64-bit seed. That's a useful starting point for a particular generator, but it isn't automatically the number of visibly different worlds. Different seeds can produce some of the same features, and counting entire worlds is a different question from counting seeds.
If you include multiple versions, you can count seed and generator combinations. But that still isn't necessarily a count of unique worlds, because some combinations may generate the same results.
Reply to this answer
Multiplying 2^64 by the number of generation updates gives you a rough count of seed and update combinations, not proof that every combination produces a unique world. An update might change structures without changing every part of the terrain, for example.
The number of updates also depends on where you draw the line. Are you counting every release with a small generation tweak, or only major overhauls? You need that rule before the multiplication means much.
Reply to this answer
Editions complicate it too. More similar terrain generation doesn't mean every structure or other generated feature matches. Treating editions as completely identical would miss differences, but doubling the count assumes every result is distinct, which isn't established either.
Reply to this answer
There's also a distinction between the world generated from a seed and the world after players change it. If builds, mining and other changes count, you're asking a much broader question than how many seeds or terrain layouts exist.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
manaBudget~Casual:
So the seed count is exact, but the unique world count depends on what counts as different?
P2button!Wobbly:
Right. You'd need to decide whether a different structure is enough, whether terrain alone matters, and which versions you're including.