I'd love to see another Shining Force game, especially one with unit promotions and those tense early battles where everyone feels fragile. How feasible would a revival be, and what should a modern entry keep or change?
How feasible would a new Shining Force game be?
Answers
The game design itself is doable. The harder question is whether the rights holder would want to fund it and whether a developer could make the numbers work. Even a modest strategy game needs art, writing, combat design, testing, and a plan to reach enough players.
A smaller project could keep the focus on a campaign and tactical battles rather than trying to match the scale of a huge modern RPG. That still wouldn't make it cheap or guarantee that a new entry happens.
Reply to this answer
Keep promotions as a big moment, not just a stat bump. Let a promoted unit gain a new role or ability so the choice changes how you use them in battle. I'd still want the basic classes to be readable, though. You shouldn't need a spreadsheet to understand what your force can do.
Reply to this answer
Those scrappy early fights are worth preserving. Low defenses make positioning and healing matter right away, but the maps need to give you enough information to make sensible choices. A modern interface could show attack ranges and expected damage without making the battles less tense.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't want a revival to be afraid of changing things. Give returning fans the tactical battles and promotions they enjoy, but make room for new scenarios and characters too. A fourth entry doesn't have to recreate every old system to feel related.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
8KlootDraft+Thimble:
That sounds good to me. Promotions would feel more rewarding if they changed your tactics as well as your numbers.