How feasible would a new Shining Force game be?

November 19, 2026 4 answers
Asked by 8KlootDraft+Thimble

I'd love to see another Shining Force game, especially one with unit promotions and those tense early battles where everyone feels fragile. How feasible would a revival be, and what should a modern entry keep or change?

Answers

mechGyro_9T

The game design itself is doable. The harder question is whether the rights holder would want to fund it and whether a developer could make the numbers work. Even a modest strategy game needs art, writing, combat design, testing, and a plan to reach enough players.

A smaller project could keep the focus on a campaign and tactical battles rather than trying to match the scale of a huge modern RPG. That still wouldn't make it cheap or guarantee that a new entry happens.

Reply to this answer
hexTile!OffDuty

Keep promotions as a big moment, not just a stat bump. Let a promoted unit gain a new role or ability so the choice changes how you use them in battle. I'd still want the basic classes to be readable, though. You shouldn't need a spreadsheet to understand what your force can do.

8KlootDraft+Thimble:

That sounds good to me. Promotions would feel more rewarding if they changed your tactics as well as your numbers.

Reply to this answer
critRoll~Unclear

Those scrappy early fights are worth preserving. Low defenses make positioning and healing matter right away, but the maps need to give you enough information to make sensible choices. A modern interface could show attack ranges and expected damage without making the battles less tense.

Reply to this answer
manaTithe_6P

I wouldn't want a revival to be afraid of changing things. Give returning fans the tactical battles and promotions they enjoy, but make room for new scenarios and characters too. A fourth entry doesn't have to recreate every old system to feel related.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions