What is the earliest published tabletop RPG with something like a push mechanic? I mean spending a resource to roll more dice after a poor skill check, with some chance of further risk. A flat bonus that guarantees an improvement would not quite fit.
How far back does the push mechanic in tabletop RPGs go?
Answers
The definition matters a lot here. A resource spent before a roll to add dice is different from spending one after a failure to try again. A reroll can still fail, but that is not necessarily the same as risking an extra consequence.
For an earliest example, I'd look for a published rule that specifies when the resource is spent, what gets rolled, and what can go wrong. Without a candidate and a publication date, I would not put a first game on it.
Reply to this answer
Blades in the Dark is one possible reference point, but familiarity with that game doesn't establish where the idea started. Vampire and Werewolf also have differing versions of the concept, so comparing their exact rules and edition dates would be a useful next step.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P9meterRoute+Kimchi:
The version I'm most curious about is the one used after a bad roll, where spending the resource gives you another chance rather than a guaranteed fix.