I've heard Sword World is a Japanese fantasy RPG that uses six-sided dice. How does it compare with D&D, and was it really the reason D&D never became popular in Japan?
How does Sword World compare with D&D in Japan?
Answers
I'd be cautious about the idea that Sword World simply pushed D&D aside. D&D was already being played by some early Japanese tabletop gamers before Sword World existed. That doesn't tell us how popular either game is today, though, or settle how their sales compare.
Reply to this answer
Record of Lodoss War is often brought up in this comparison because it began as a published replay of a D&D game. A replay presents the events of a tabletop game for readers, rather than just giving them rules or a standalone novel.
There's a common story that a rejected licensing request directly led to Sword World becoming a Lodoss RPG. I'd treat that neat version with caution. The connection is worth exploring, but the history shouldn't be reduced to one cause.
Reply to this answer
Using six-sided dice makes Sword World sound more accessible than a game needing several different die shapes, especially if those were hard to find locally. But that alone doesn't explain why one game would sell better. I'd want more evidence before treating dice availability as the deciding factor.
Reply to this answer
For design, the shared fantasy RPG territory and the different dice are a starting point, not enough to say how similarly they play. A useful comparison would look at character creation, combat and advancement in a particular edition of each game. This discussion doesn't give enough detail to make that comparison fairly.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
CRTcolorBars_7J:
So the timeline is more complicated than Sword World arriving first. That clears up part of what I was wondering.