How do you make Legends in the Mist feel less forced?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by _WarmupQueue_7

Our group is a couple of sessions into Legends in the Mist, and we keep struggling to fit tags into what we want to do. It also feels like we're making up a lot as we go.

We're more used to OSR-style play. How do you approach the storytelling in this game, especially if you want a longer campaign?

Answers

GBClinkPortRookie

Try starting with what the character actually does in the scene, then look at the tags. If a tag clearly helps explain how they do it, bring it in. If you have to twist the description to make it fit, let it go for that action.

That may feel backwards if you're used to looking at a character sheet for available abilities. The scene still matters. The tags give you a way to connect the character's established traits to what's happening, rather than requiring you to invent a new justification for every move.

_WarmupQueue_7:

That helps. We've probably been looking at the tags first and trying to build every action around them.

Reply to this answer
scrimBanjoTactic

Making things up together doesn't have to mean the world has no consistency. Once the group establishes something in play, treat it as part of the setting going forward. Keep a few notes on people, places, unresolved problems and changes caused by the characters.

For a longer campaign, those details give everyone material to build on. You don't need to plan an entire plot in advance, but consequences from earlier sessions can make later choices feel connected.

Reply to this answer
kartToeBrakeMaybe

It might help to separate two frustrations. Are the tags getting in the way of describing actions, or does the group dislike being asked to contribute to the fiction? Those call for different fixes.

For the first, slow down and talk through a scene together without trying to optimize every tag. For the second, agree on how much players want to establish and how much they want the person running the game to decide. A narrative-first game can still have surprises, but the group may need to settle on a style that feels comfortable.

Reply to this answer
shmupLockstep_4M

Also, it's okay if this just isn't your group's kind of game. Wanting to like a book and enjoying its procedures at the table are different things. Give it a little more room if you're curious, but there's no need to force a long campaign.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions