Some tabletop RPG projects take years to fulfill, while publishers also announce new campaigns. What should customers look for when deciding whether a delay is reasonable or a warning sign?
How do you judge a publisher when an indie RPG keeps getting delayed?
Answers
Look at what is actually unfinished, not just the age of the campaign. A late core book is different from a game that shipped but still has supplements or other rewards outstanding. Both matter, but they affect backers differently.
For example, Magpie Games canceled two remaining Cartel supplements after years of outstanding work. The publisher said the books still needed editing and design and were no longer viable on a reasonable timeline. It offered affected physical-book backers a cash refund or a larger amount in store credit. That gives those backers a clearer choice than another indefinite delay, though it doesn't deliver the promised books.
Reply to this answer
I'd pay close attention to the updates. Are they specific about what's left, who's responsible for it, and what happens next? A revised estimate can be useful, but a date without any explanation of the work behind it doesn't tell me much.
Silence or repeated vague promises make it harder for customers to decide whether to keep waiting. A candid update saying something cannot be completed is disappointing, but at least people know where they stand.
Reply to this answer
Delaying a new campaign can be a good sign. Magpie pushed back the Masks second edition campaign after feedback that the game might change too much and that the campaign might not show the finished product. More development before asking for money could make the offer easier to evaluate.
That doesn't automatically settle concerns about older projects, though. I'd consider the new campaign's readiness and the publisher's outstanding commitments as separate questions.
Reply to this answer
For a customer, the simplest option is to wait until the book is actually available. Crowdfunding means accepting that plans can change, and a campaign page isn't the same thing as a finished product on a shelf.
If you do back, check which rewards you are paying for and what the publisher has said about their completion. Decide whether you're comfortable with that money being tied up for an uncertain amount of time.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P33!GuardMargin:
Cash and store credit aren't interchangeable, either. The extra credit is only useful if you want something else from that publisher.