When players question someone in a mystery, they sometimes ask for everything the person knows so they don't miss a clue. How can I make those conversations more engaging without making players guess the exact right question?
How do you handle players asking an NPC to tell them everything?
Answers
Give them the obvious, relevant information. A cooperative witness can summarize what happened without a full interrogation, and withholding the basic clue because the players phrased a question broadly can feel arbitrary.
Then let follow-up questions uncover details the witness didn't think were relevant. Someone might mention seeing a visitor near the missing diamond, but only recall the visitor's unusual coat when asked what they looked like. The mystery can still be about what the players do with the information.
Reply to this answer
Ask the players what they mean by everything. Are they trying to learn who had access, establish a timeline, or find out why the witness is nervous? They can tell you their characters' approach without acting out every question word for word.
Once you know their focus, summarize the conversation and give them what that line of questioning would reasonably reveal. If they want to roleplay a tense exchange, zoom in on that part.
Reply to this answer
Think about the NPC's perspective rather than treating them like a searchable database. They may not know what matters, may be mistaken, or may have a reason to avoid a subject. A willing witness and a frightened accomplice should respond differently to the same request.
Give the players something they can react to, though. If the person is hesitant about the visitor, let that hesitation show. Otherwise there's not much for the group to investigate.
GBCtileMapper:
And being mistaken doesn't have to mean lying. A witness can be confident and still have a limited view of what happened.
Reply to this answer
Talk to the group about the pattern outside the game. Asking for everything might be their way of avoiding missed clues, while you want more back and forth. You could agree that broad questions get the essential facts, with extra detail available through follow-up questions or other investigation.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
casualQueueBanter:
That makes sense. The broad question gets the starting point, and specific questions help flesh it out.